Iraheta, the smokey-voiced 17-year-old rocker chick from Southern California, was the odd person out after failing to win voters over with her version of Janis Joplin’s “Cry Baby.” This, despite the fact Danny Gokey made a brutal nightmare of Aerolsmith’s “Dream On.” Many thought Allison had a lock on a Top 3 spot after her rousing duet with Adam Lambert .